Southwest Airlines has been my favorite airline for a long time – I’ve written about them often in this blog and talk about them often in my speeches. I’m a Southwest fan not only because of positive experiences, but also because their success and almost cult-like following has been a great case study as a speaker and consultant.
But I’ve noticed a disturbing trend over the last several flights I’ve had with them. It seems that more and more of their employees have adopted what I would call an “attitude of arrogance.” Since most interactions are with flight attendants, this trend has been most noticeable with them. Whereas in the past just about every flight attendant was personable, funny, and helpful, I’m seeing more flight attendants being standoffish, mechanical, and (even worse) impatient with passengers who might be struggling with overhead bag space or trying to find seats for the whole family.
On a Southwest flight last week, in fact, I watched a flight attendant work herself into a huff as a mom was making sure her children all had seats before she sat down. Yes, the mom was slowing down the boarding process, but the flight attendant should have helped out rather than embarrassing the mom in front of a planeload full of passengers. By helping, the flight attendant would’ve sped up the process and saved the mom’s dignity and peace of mind.
Southwest has never been a perfect airline; I’ve seen a few less-than-stellar Southwest employees before. But those instances were rare. But lately I’ve noticed “unSouthwest-like” behaviors becoming more common with more employees. I don’t know about you, but I feel let down when a trusted organization violates a trust that has been built up over many years. It almost feels like a close friend violating a trust. And once an organization begins to lose the trust of their loyal customers, lost loyalty isn’t far behind.
I’m hoping that Southwest Airlines hasn’t gotten too big for its britches. But the attitude of some of their employees is one of resting on their reputation. It’s as though they’re saying to passengers, “We’re doing you a favor by allowing you to fly an airline with a reputation as legendary as ours.” Well, they should study the fates of other once successful companies that started taking their success for granted such as General Motors, Circuit City, Woolworth’s, Eastern Airlines, Washington Mutual, Bennigan’s and the list goes on.
The lesson here is that no matter how stellar your organization’s reputation is, that reputation is very fragile. Customers might be willing to forgive the occasional blip in service, but they won’t forgive arrogance. They have too many choices, and every one of your competitors would be giddy to get your customers’ business. Each of your employees must be hungry to build solid customer relationships, and the only way to do that is to treat customers with the care and respect that demonstrates that you value their business and are honored that customers have chosen to do business with you.
Do your customers feel you VALUE their business and that you are HONORED they’ve chosen to do business with you?
Is there even a hint of arrogance creeping into your performance?
Other articles you might like:
- Your attitude is showing
- Airlines ranked for customer service; Continental dominates
- Do You Deliver Jaw Dropping Customer Service?
- Showing up is just not enough!
- Continental Airlines boosts customer service by cutting free food. Huh?




Kevin I’ve never flown with SW but refer to them often as examplers of how to deliver an experience even at budget prices. I wonder what the management would have to say on the comments you make? Are there any other clues that SW is on the cusp of going the way of Starbucks?
Hi Mark – You make a good point, referencing Starbucks. Both companies started with a strong customer-centric culture and grew with that as a foundation. Can they maintain the same customer focus but at a larger size?
Anyone else have similarly unfortunate experiences with Southwest Airlines? We’d love to hear about them.
Thanks for sharing your thoughts Mark!
Kevin Stirtz
The Amazing Service Guy
Dennis, with all due respect I think you should point out that this event happened back in December and that this post ran on December 24. I would hope that folks will check out http://dennissnowblog.com/2010/01/07/the-curse-of-arrogance-an-update/
thanks,
Brian Lusk
Southwest Airlines
Brian – thanks for adding the link to Dennis’ follow-up post. Regarding your comment about the date, I don’t see the importance. Dennis’ post describes what he observed as one of your customers. If it happened 3 or 4 years ago that might be different. But less than two months does not seem relevant. If I am missing something, please help me understand. Thanks again for your comments.
Kevin Stirtz
AmazingServiceGuy.com
Brian, I appreciate your comment about my article. Yes, I did get a thoughtful note from the VP of Inflight Services for Southwest as a result of my original post. The link in your comment will bring readers to the update.
Also, I want to stress that I am still a Southwest fan. I have simply noticed a downward trend in service lately and was concerned (because I’m a fan). Overall, Southwest’s service is still the best in the business. But, it’s important not to rest on your laurels and to continue to stress to your employees that you’re only as good as your last customer interaction.
Thanks for commenting!
Dennis